The Seanad Éireann Public Consultation Committee is inviting public submissions on Ireland’s Fourth Periodic Report under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). The issue of direct provision is one that the UN Human Rights Committee, the independent body responsible for assessing Ireland’s compliance with the ICCPR, has asked the Irish government to provide information on (see ICCPR list of issues and Ireland’s reply to list of issues).
The issue of direct provision was raised by a number of shadow reports from civil society organisations, in particular by the Free Legal Advice Centres (here), the Irish Human Rights Commission (here) , the Irish Council of Civil Liberties (here) and the Irish Refugee Council (here). The enormous work by these organisations have ensured that the issue of direct provision for asylum seekers remains on the UN human rights agenda.
I have made a submission on The System of Direct Provision and Ireland’s Obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights to the Seanad Public Consultation Committee. In this submission, I note that all human rights are interdependent and indivisible, violations of economic, social and cultural rights may lead to violations of civil and political rights. The three core arguments I make to the Seanad Éireann Public Consultation Committee are:
- Ireland is fully aware of the significant negative impact that direct provision is having on a large number of families and individuals.
- The direct provision complaints system lacks any independent oversight. This must be remedied as a matter of urgency.
- The operation of the direct provision system is bordering on inhuman and degrading treatment, given the length of time individuals and families will have to remain in the system. Given the level of social control, poverty and enforced idleness imposed on asylum seekers for several years, the State is also violating rights to private and family life and rights to be treated equally before the law.
You can read my full submission here.